Hello! And welcome to another edition of “Old-Ass Mixtape Review”. It’s been three-and-one-half years since I’ve written one of these, but I’ve been thinking about returning to it for a while now, so here we are. If you’re not familiar with my semi-recurring “Old-Ass Mixtape Review” posts, the vague idea is that I take an old (-ass) mixtape I made in the Before Times (mostly the 90’s through early-to-mid 2000’s), I listen to it in the first time in 10 or more years, and I write about it. That’s what we in the business call a “writing prompt”. I’m just kidding, I’m not in the writing business. I’m too busy givin this shit away.
I was gonna include a video here for the Supersuckers song “Givin it Away”, but Google and YouTube are both trying to gaslight me into thinking the song never even existed. I know that it does exist, but you’ll have to hang out and listen to How the Supersuckers Became the Greatest Rock ‘n’ Roll Band in the World on CD with me if you wanna hear it. In addition to being a kick-ass song, it also contains the line, “don’t be callin me no whore, cause I’m givin it away”, and I wanted to use those lyrics in the caption of the video, but since I can’t do that, I’m gonna share a different Supersuckers song.
Just for funsies, here’s the top result from when I searched “Supersuckers givin it away” on YouTube:
Here’s the twist with this ongoing writing exercise: I’m only reviewing tapes that don’t have a track listing, which means I have no way of knowing what is on said tapes until I listen. How exciting!

Speaking of exciting, I’m off work (paid) until about a week into the new year, and as of right now, I’m planning to be as productive as possible, while still allowing plenty of time to relax as much as I possibly can in spite of the impending doom that is the Final Form of the United States of America: a literal oligarchy made up of racist billionaire shitheads and racist fundamentalist religious dickheads, all of them sex pests.
I’m very much looking forward to forgetting that I even have a job while I spend my leisure time reading, watching Murder, She Wrote, and lookin at birds, and my productive time giving the house a much-needed cleaning/rearranging and writing as much as possible, which is why we’re here right now.
Today’s installment is the first volume in a series of mixtapes I made for myself between probably 2000 and 2005. When I made the original Awesome Mixtape #6, I didn’t plan on it becoming a series, but life comes at you pretty fast, and next thing you know, I’ve made seven of them. I don’t know where Volume 3 is anymore, so I only own six of them today. This one and Volume 7 have no track listing (V7 doesn’t even have a J-card), so, get stoked for even more of this nonsense I guess.

Oh, a quick credit-where-credit-is-due bit: I stole the title of the tape series from Boogie Nights, which is a fantastic movie that I simply cannot watch anymore, due to the devastating sadness and despair it wroughts upon me. And I suppose I should get the technical mumbo jumbo out of the way before we get started: we’re workin with a standard 90-minute Sony High Fidelity Type I cassette here. I don’t really know what that means, but if you click that link, you can learn a lot about blank audio cassettes. I expect the sound will be adequate. Certainly better than “Old-Ass Mixtape Review, Volume 1: Beloved Songs“.

Side A
Danny Elfman – “The Simpsons Main Title Theme (Extended Version)”
This is one of two songs I knew for sure was on this tape (the other one will be coming up later on Side A). Danny Elfman once named this the song that’ll be mentioned in his obituary. I haven’t watched an episode of The Simpsons since the Futurama crossover 10-12 years ago, but The Simpsons from seasons 1-10 is one of my favorite shows of all time.
Clutch – “Rats”
“Build a better man trap, and the rats will beat a path to your door.” So shouteth Neil Fallon, and who am I to argue with the frontman of one of the greatest rock ‘n’ roll bands of all time? This is one of my favorite Clutch songs, so it’s not surprising to me that the tape drags a bit throughout, as I likely rewound this one a lot. I got to hear it live for the first time like 18 months ago, which was the last time I saw them, and which was also the 12th time I’ve seen them. I missed out on lucky number 13 back in September, but they pretty much only stop touring in order to record new albums, so I know I’ll get another chance soon.
Dropkick Murphys – “Noble”
I wrote a bit about Dropkick Murphys in a Louder Than Life-related post recently, so I won’t bother to discuss them here, but I absolutely fuckin love this song.
Avail – “Lombardy St.” (acoustic)
I love Avail. I’m fortunate to have seen frontman Tim Barry live three times, but I missed at least that many chances to see Avail live before they broke up, and that’s a bummer, because at this point whenever they do play shows, they end up selling before I even find out about them, plus they’re usually on the east coast anyway. I keep hoping they’ll appear on a Louder Than Life lineup one of these years, but so far, no dice.
Anyway, this version of “Lombardy St.” is originally from The Fall of Richmond, a split single with a band called (Young) Pioneers, about whom I recall nothing. The heavier original version is on their 1998 album Over the James. That version is also fantastic, as is the rest of that album, as is pretty much everything Avail ever released. You should listen to Avail, and Tim Barry.
The Velvet Underground – “I’m Waiting for the Man”
I’m a sucker for an unconventional vocalist singing over a jangly guitar. See also: The Tragically Hip, R.E.M., Hüsker Dü, et al, so you know this song is right up my proverbial alley.
Here’s a fun story: in my younger, dumber, drunker days, I was hanging out at Owen, Ian, and Mike’s place, as I often did. Some sort of small, impromptu gathering had broken out, as tended to be the case on a Friday evening. I overindulged on Schnapps and/or Miller High Life, as one does when one is me at the age of twenty-two. Thankfully I had the good sense to leave my car parked and stay the night, and I passed out on the couch in the “sitting” room, which connected the living room with the kitchen, and which almost certainly used to be the fancy dining room before the house was divided in two.
While their place made for a fantastic party pad, it was sorely lacking in one particular way: the two-story, three bedroom duplex with semi-finished basement only had one bathroom, and it was at the top of the stairs on the second floor, where it shared a very thin wall with one of the bedrooms.
My eyes shot open. I could tell it was morning, because I could see pretty clearly, and I deduced it was quite early, as the entire first floor was shaded. A sudden urgency took hold of me — an urgency I think I’ve not experienced since.
I shot off the couch and leapt up those stairs in personal record time, unleashing approximately 100 gallons of vomit into a toilet that as many as 20 people had used to go number 1 and number 2 in the past 12 hours. I’m not really a math guy, but that definitely adds up to “86 me”.
I thought the unholy slurry of sadness, regrets, and bad decisions would never stop coming out of me, but eventually it did, whereupon I became aware of the t h r o b b i n g in my skull. In those days, I hadn’t yet developed the good sense to also drink water while drinking alcohol.
“Hey buddy, you gonna make it?” I turned my head as far as I could manage, which ended up being about two inches, which was just enough to make out the image of Owen standing in the doorway in his underwear, his hair like an impressionist Troll doll. I mumbled some kind of reply, and he helped me back down the stairs to the couch, and brought me a glass of water and a trash can. I closed my eyes and made an official proclamation that I was never going to drink again as Owen went back to bed.
My eyes shot open. The sun was coming in the living room windows now, but it still hadn’t reached me. I was glad about that, because I’m very warm-natured, and the last thing I needed was to start sweating on that disgusting couch. I heard voices coming from the kitchen, and I heard music playing, although I can’t remember who was talking, or what the song was. I also can’t remember how I managed to get all of my throwup in the trash can, but I know that I did. A sudden movement caught my attention from across the narrow room. It was Mike, sitting in a chair, throwing up into the book he was reading. I groaned “I’m sorry Mike!” and closed my eyes, wondering if I’d ever feel okay again.
A mellow, repetitive guitar jangle eased my eyes open as weird, warbly, monotone voice filled the room. The sun was higher now, coming in the window directly above me. It cast a soft, bright light on the potted heartleaf philodendron hanging from the ceiling. I instantly knew I had finished puking, at least for the day. I looked across the room to see Mike contentedly eating Taco Bell. I said “I’m sorry Mike,” and he laughed. “That’s okay, man, it happens to the best of us. I got an extra taco if you’re hungry. You feel like eating?”
I did feel like eating, and sat on that couch in the warm sun and ate a taco with my friend and let this beautiful, melancholy song about buying heroin take a heretofore unrecognized empty spot in my soul and fill it with a glow that matched the one that filled that room. That was the first time that “I’m Waiting For the Man” made me realize things were gonna be okay.
Stubborn All-Stars – “Tin Spam”
I don’t actually know much of anything about this band, but I used to own their debut album Open Season, and I listened to it a lot. This is the first song from that album. I still put it on mixes to this day. I dig plenty of reggae, ska, and ska-punk, but that sweet spot of Jamaican ska/rock steady is my jam.
Descendents – “Everything Sux”/”Coffee Mug”
I likely wouldn’t be sitting here writing these words without the Descendents (and their companion band, ALL). They got me through some shit in my early-twenties. This is an unusual selection, as I don’t normally put two songs in a row by the same band on my mixes (unless the whole mix is twofers, or it’s a streaming mix, which I pretty much always shuffle). Knowing the way I think, I’m guessing I put these two songs in a row because they’re both very short, and they feel like spiritual siblings. The tape slows down/drags just a bit toward the end of “Coffee Mug”, but it corrects itself pretty quickly.
Got up on the wrong side of life this morning, nothing today is gonna go my way.
The Bouncing Souls – “Neurotic”
I absolutely 100% would not be here writing these words without The Bouncing Souls. This band was everything to me for about four years in my early-to-mid twenties. I got to meet them once, at the last Warped Tour I ever attended (2000). Pete complimented my shirt (which I left in Austin when I moved back home, because someone washed a mixed load on hot and it turned the shirt pink), and Brian assured me that they, too, were still alive because of their music. It was a good day. I’ll write more about The Bouncing Souls one of these days.
The Pavers – “Mr. Sheperd’s Bandage”
Scott Reynolds was the second vocalist for ALL, the band that the Descendents became after Milo went to college the second time. I have a long overdue thing about ALL/Descendents to write one of these days. Anyway, Scott sang on three studio albums and one live album, and a handful of other songs that were included as B-sides on singles, then he left ALL and moved to the Pacific Northwest, where he joined forces with the late, great Trevor Lanigan (My Name, Wretch Like Me) to form a band called Goodbye Harry. They released two excellent albums before breaking up, after which Scott moved back home to Upstate New York, where he and some friends formed another amazing band called The Pavers, which, if you recall from the beginning of this entry, is this band right here.
Scott has gone on to record a bunch other of great stuff under various names, including his own. You should check out his work. This song is about a WW2 veteran who was injured at the Battle of Anzio. It makes me cry any time I pay attention to the lyrics.
Speaking of lyrics, I’m gonna share them, because they are exceptionally good:
Oh, a million miles an hour
A thousand times a night
I watch them burn red
Red rockets cross my sight
1944, Second World War
At Anzio we kicked in Mussolini’s door
That’s when it came
German steel, Italian rain
Sent razors through my legs, and sent me back home
Open up my eyes
Lovely VA nurse
Said “Mr. Shepherd, you’ve made it through the worst.”
But she don’t know what she means
‘Cause she ain’t seen what I’ve seen
The worst gets worse every night in every dream
Hot rockets hiss, hard violence, soft prom night kiss
The first 18 years add up to this
Whispered on the rocket’s hiss
It goes on and on and on and on
Seems like a thousand years fell down, down on him
A thousand fears ground down all around him
Jagged edge gone soft with time
And Mr. Shepherd’s just fine
At least that’s what we believe,
‘Cause we don’t want to see
He’s still laid bare to the bone below his knee.
Here he comes again
I recognize his walk
Sit right there, Mr. Shepherd, please don’t talk
White cotton gauze still running red without a pause
While everyone forgets what caused
The horror there beneath the gauze
It goes on and on and on and on
For Mr. Shepherd
Public Enemy – “By the Time I Get to Arizona”
This is the other song that I knew for certain was a part of this mix, but I didn’t remember where it fell. Here, apparently. It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back and Fear of a Black Planet are obviously important and groundbreaking releases from the legendary hip-hop group, but their fourth album, Apocalypse ’91…the Enemy Strikes Black is the first one I heard (thanks in part to my homeboy Travis, as well as their collaboration with Anthrax), and it’s still my favorite. This song is amazing.
Fishbone – “Sunless Saturday”
I don’t listen to enough Fishbone, but I’ve probably listened to this song 500 times since I first heard it in the early 90’s.
Here’s a blog-only bonus track – “Sunless Saturday” live on The Arsenio Hall Show.
Rollins Band – “Do It”
I was a bonafide Henry Rollins fanboy in my late teens and very early twenties. I still dig pretty much all of his recorded musical output up to and including Rollins Band’s 1997 album Come in and Burn, but I don’t listen to it much anymore. I wrote once on my old blog about embarrassing myself when I met him on the Come in and Burn tour, and you can read about that here if you’d like. It’s a pretty funny story.
The Mothers of Invention – “My Guitar Wants to Kill Your Mama”
I tried to get into Frank Zappa around the same time I was getting into Henry Rollins and The Velvet Underground, and I owned three CDs at one point, but for the most part, I could never really get past the weirdness. I like some pretty fuckin weird stuff, but by and large, Zappa’s music just doesn’t do much for me. As a cultural icon/seemingly pretty fuckin cool guy, however, I’m all in on Frank Zappa. And I do still love this song.
Del Shannon – “Runaway”
I’ve loved this song since I was a little kid. I especially dig Del’s raspy vocals in the chorus. I signed up to sing it at karaoke one night, not knowing if I’d be able to pull off the key change in the chorus, and was pleasantly surprised to find that I could. I’m pretty confident I would not be able to do that anymore. One last thing: ever since I first heard the band Down By Law, I’ve imagined them covering this. I think Dave Smalley’s voice would sound great on it.
H2O – “Nazi Punks Fuck Off”
H2O is another band that helped me through it when I was a li’l sad boi. I don’t listen to them much anymore, but they’ll always hold a special place in my heart, and I’d see them live again in a heartbeat. They were my gateway to positive hardcore, and, like Henry Rollins/Rollins Band, they helped me understand that I was worth more than I thought. This song first appeared on a compilation that I picked up at Warped Tour ’99 called Stop Racism: Anti-Racist Action, the Benefit CD. Warped Tour ’99 is also one of the times where I missed seeing Avail live. It’s the circle of life, and it moves us all.
Green Day – “The Ballad of Wilhelm Fink”
This song rules, and is one of my favorite Green Day songs. It originally appeared on Short Music for Short People, a Fat Wreck Chords CD compilation of 101 bands performing 30 second songs (Bad Religion‘s song is actually 45 seconds long, but Greg Graffin can’t help himself). I foolishly got rid of my copy of this CD when I moved back from Austin, and that was dumb. It has some certified bangers on it.
Less Than Jake – “Anchor”
Ooh, here’s another Certified Banger from Short Music. Less Than Jake is a band that I don’t really listen to on purpose, but I’ve always enjoy them when I hear them. I absolutely love the *ding* at the end of the song. At this point, I feel like we’re gonna get at least one more song from SMfSP.
AFI – “Hearts Frozen Solid, Thawed Once More by the Spring of Rage, Despair and Hopelessness”
And I was right. I always liked to cram as many short songs as possible on the end of tape sides, to both maximize the rockin and minimize the blank space. What to say about AFI…Davey Havok is pretty ridiculous, and I think I dislike more of their recorded output than I like, but when AFI makes a great song, AFI makes a great fuckin song. I saw them on that same Warped Tour where I met The Bouncing Souls (H2O was there, too), and they were pretty dope live, even in the middle of the day. I’d catch them live again if I could, but I imagine I’d be a grumpy old piece of shit for most of the show, because I imagine they’d play mostly stuff from after 1997, and because I’m a grumpy old piece of shit.
The clicking and muddiness that follows AFI indicate that I likely tried to add one more song, but nothing would fit. Cue sad trombone sound.
Okay, I’m gonna wrap this up. I’ll get around to Side B ASAP. Maybe even tomorrow (but don’t hold your breath). Thanks for reading!


